when you do create the new thread, will you let me know where it is??? I am considering both the SAS or SAR. Currently have BMW K1600GT and S1000XR
Yes, sir. I am planning a long trip this week to the Pig Trails in Arkansas and if I go, I will write a better review after the trip. I am bit overworked this week so am not sure if I will make the trip. I did take the SAS through some twisties here in Texas (not a lot but enough to get a feel for the bike and to also add some miles for the first service). I have a break-in route I have used for many bikes, from H-D to small Hondas, which has twisties, dirt roads, highways, etc. to learn a new bike. The SAS was much nicer that my 890 but, honestly, I felt the HD Pan America was smoother, more comfortable and more nimble on this route (too bad all those HD electrical issues!). I am only 5-9, and was expecting the SAS to be a bit tall for me but in reality, I was a bit uncomfortable on it as the knee angle was odd. I had already ordered a low seat but now realize that was a mistake. I will change it to the normal Comfort seat. I have also ordered a seat cover from Tappezzeria to put on the stock seat. I am not sure how else to fix this knee angle. I will also have to get risers, not because I am tall but because the bar angle is just awkward for me and my right wrist was aching after just a few hours - I have never experienced this on any of my previous bikes and no amount of adjustments could fix the issue. The power of the bike is nice. The cornering is nice. I could care less about Adaptive Cruise Control as I feel it may allow a rider to become complacent, but I did test it and it did work (I had an issue bringing the bike home not realizing it was in offroad mode, so no ABS and no cruise, through rain on the interstate in stop and go traffic, so I was 'old school cool' without the tech, like an idiot!). Like all KTMs, the bike vibrates from the engine. I do not mind.
I have read a lot about wind buffeting but I was pleasantly surprised at how quiet and how little wind I experience. The only wind issues was in wide open areas, on the Interstate, riding at about 75mph, and for some reason I had wind coming up from between the tank and my chest, lifting my helmet. It was odd and yet another thing never experienced before. It was not an issue, just strange to me. I would say the HD and the SAS have about the same wind protection with the SAS actually being a bit quieter and smoother.
The biggest issues I had with the SAS, which would be the same for the SAR, are the left hand buttons and the instrument screen. On the controls, as many people have commented, the new turn signal switch is just terrible. The switch on the 890 is nice, works and could have easily been used for the SAS/SAR. I have a lot of trouble canceling the signal. I know, it will cancel itself after 10 seconds, or something like that, but when lane changing, I want that signal canceled immediately so as not to confuse heavy traffic. Sadly, I was only able to cancel the signal about 25% of the time with the remaining being a distraction in frustration. The instrument screen is very crisp and easy to read. The issue is the angle. Even trying all three tilt settings, the screen is always reflecting light into my face if the sun is overhead or behind me. It was literally blinding sometimes and I had to sit oddly to avoid the light. I was also not able to see the screen for well over 60% of my riding, which means not knowing the speed, which is just not acceptable. Maybe it is just because of my shorter height, but I feel this is a major design issue. I have already ordered an anti-glare screen protector and when I get my GPS mount, which uses the same backing bracket for the TFT, I will see if I can put some rubber spacers behind the screen to create a better angle.
As for comparing the SAS and SAR, the issues I have would be the same for either. I do not know your height, but if you are riding the K1600GT, I do not think this will be an issue. I do enough off road riding that I feel the SAR would have been better but I also do more on road (70-30?). I have already ordered wire wheels. The electronic suspension is nice but there is a LOT of variables with it and I am old-school, so feel wrenching a few clicks on the springs is not a bad thing and more my style. That being said, the electronic suspension on the HD Pan America is very, very nice and much better that the SAS, in my opinion. Now, I only have a fraction of the time on the SAS as the HDPA, so that opinion may change with experience in adjusting settings. Do I think this is justification to get the SAS over the SAR, no, not at all. It is just a nice luxury and also another failure point (not that it will fail).
I guess, as others in this thread have said, it comes down to riding style. If you are planning a BDR, maybe the SAR is better. If you are only going to be on forest roads offroad or only on paved roads, the SAS makes more sense. For me, I just jerked my knee, frustrated that the HD PA was back in the shop when I had a trip to Arkansas planned. The SAS was available, close, and ready to go from a dealership I trust (Mainland Cycle Center, La Marque, Texas - Michael has sold me two motorcycles now, only via email, without any hassles and very easily), so I reacted and bought it. If I had known another used 2022 SAR would come available within 24 hours, yes, I would have waited and bought it. As I said, I was seriously considering buying it, anyway, and probably would have if I had buyers for my HD PA and KTM 890 (both for sale). I rode the HD PA from Farmington, NM to El Paso, TX, diagonally, primarily only on dirt roads, forest roads, 4x4 roads, etc., and it handled very well, despite the stock tires which are road biased. I have full confidence the SAS, with proper spoke wheels, would be able to equal or match the comfort and confidence I had on the HD PA along the same route, which also covered a great deal of the NMBDR route. I had cameras with me but because of electrical issues with the Pan America, I could not charge anything so all my stuff was dead within hours, including my phone. Luckily, being from NM, I know those roads and trails pretty well and was not concerned about GPS or maps (okay, I did manage to take one weird route that landed me into single-track, which I decided to backtrack and avoid).
I apologize for over-writing on the SAR thread, but I did feel CDESJAR deserved a better response that, "I will write more later..." since he is shopping now.